Has your deck seen better days? Maybe your stairs are uneven, or you’ve got some pesky nails that keep sticking out. Big or small, you need to know how to fix these issues. You’re probably asking the big question: should I remodel it or replace it entirely? How do you know what’s best? The answer truly depends on your deck’s condition, structure, and long-term goals. Here’s exactly how to decide which option makes the most sense for your home and budget.
Honest Inspection
Take a very close look at your structure. Check every post, every floorboard, every nail. You should be looking for rot, damage, or warping in wood. Watch out for loose railings, uneven boards, or unstable footings. Always consider the age of your deck. If it’s about to be about 15-20 years old, it is likely due for a full replacement.
When a Remodel Makes Sense
If your foundation and framing are solid and structurally sound, and most issues seem to be cosmetic, your deck is in good shape for a remodel. Issues like faded boards, loose screws, and weathered railings are all easy fixes through some remodeling. A remodel can include replacing deck boards or railings, adding new features (lighting, stairs, seating, or pergola), resealing or re-staining, or upgrading materials.
When It’s Time for a Full Replacement
If your structure is at all compromised by things like rot and age, a full replacement is likely unavoidable. Decks are permanently exposed to the elements and naturally succumb to them over time, so full replacement is par for the course. If you notice sagging or soft spots, or any unstable sections, these are all signs of serious damage and indicators that replacement is necessary.
How Do You Decide?
Consider all factors. Based on your budget, which option makes more sense? Is your deck too young to be replaced? Or too old to carry the weight of all your outdoor furniture and your loved ones? What issues do you need solved?
The Bottom Line
If you just have a couple of issues that need to be touched up, or you are just looking to upgrade, a remodel is an excellent choice. However, if you have more serious issues with your deck, a full replacement may be necessary. Contact your Armstrong Construction Specialist today to help you evaluate which option is best.
